Single Shard, A

___________________
by Park, Linda Sue. (Clarion, 2001 ISBN 0395978270. Order Info.) Novel. Grades 4+.

___________________

Review

cover art

In this Newbery Award winner Tree-ear is homeless, living under a bridge in twelfth-century Korea. A physically disabled man, the proud and ethical Crane-man, is raising him. Tree-ear loves to hide behind one of the master potters' houses in the village and watch Master Min use the potter's wheel to make delicate and beautiful celadon pottery. When Tree-ear accidentally breaks one of Min's pieces, he must work for Min to pay for the damage. Tree-ear's constant hope is that Min will teach him to use the potter's wheel.

Min is the best potter in the village. He is a gruff perfectionist and never displays anything but disapproval for Tree-ear's work. When Tree-ear has paid off his debt, Min agrees to let Tree-ear continue to work in exchange for food. Still, he never allows Tree-ear to try to make pottery himself. Tree-ear must collect wood to fire the kiln, collect clay from the riverbank, and filter the clay over and over and over again in pits to get the fine consistency the master needs.

When the emperor's assistant comes to the village of potters to assign a new commission, the potters become desperate, spending long hours making their best possible pieces. Tree-ear spies on one of the other potters and discovers he has created a new technique for making inlaid designs of white clay in his pieces. Tree-ear must make an ethical decision about whether or not to tell his master. He desperately wants his master to get the emperor's commission and knows that Min is the much better potter, if only he knew this new technique.

When the emperor's assistant gives Min an opportunity to show that he too can create pots with this new inlay technique, Tree-ear must travel on foot for days to bring the samples to the emperor's palace. This is his first experience away from the village. When thieves attack him and smash the pots he is left with a "single shard" displaying the technique and must decide whether to turn back or to continue on to see if the emperor's assistant will consider his master's work.

A Single Shard has a surprising ability to make the reader care about something as obscure as 12th century Korean pottery. The ethical dilemmas and Tree-ear's discussions with Crane-Man about them give depth to this story. Tree-ear is believable and convincing as a homeless child who has found a passion. We empathize with him even though he is certainly a character of his time.

___________________

Things to Talk About and Notice

  • The story revolves around the work of the potters of the village and Tree-ear's fascination with it. How are people drawn toward work and art. What factors determine our passions? List some of the things that you and people you know are passionate about.

  • How does the older system of apprenticeship compare with current formal schooling systems?

  • Tree-ear and Crane-man are homeless. What do you think would be different if they were homeless in your area and in our time?

  • Master potter Min is very gruff and seldom shows any approval. Why do you think he is this way? Is there any change over the course of the story?

  • There are several ethical discussions within the story. Stop and discuss these questions and decide what you would do in this situation. How do you decide ethical questions? What are the general concerns that should be raised?

___________________

Activities

  • Find a local potter who will let you see their work and observe them at a pottery wheel.

  • It can be difficult to get access to a pottery wheel but, like Tree-ear you can experiment with other ways of working with clay. Try forming pottery out of slabs of clay and work on making something like the leaf that he works so hard on.

  • Look at an Atlas to track Tree-ear's trip.

  • Time how quickly you can walk a given distance and then guess how far you might be able to walk in a day. Compare it to other forms of transportation and how far you can travel in a day: bicycle, horse, car, train, and airplane.

  • Visit a local flea market to compare designs on china.

  • Create a timeline of Korean history and look for ways in which this story was affected by the times.

  • Research the life of royalty versus the life of the common people during the twelfth century. How does this compare with current class differences.

___________________

Related Books

  • Choi, Sook Nyul. Year of Impossible Goodbyes. Novel. Grades 5-9. Order Info.
    Sookan and her family flee the cruelty of the Japanese invaders of Korea during World War II.

  • Watkins, Yoko K. So Far from the Bamboo Grove. Novel, Fictionalized Biography. Grades 6-9. Order Info.
    This fictionalized autobiography tells the story of a Japanese family living in Korea near the end of the war.

  • Climo, Shirley. Korean Cinderella, The. Picture Book. Grades 2-5. Order Info.
    Pear Blossom is the Korean Cinderella figure who is abused by her stepmother and must perform three impossible tasks before being chosen by the magistrate to be his wife.

  • Fox, Paula Monkey Island. Novel. Grades 4-9. Order Info.
    Monkey Island is the homeless community where eleven year old Clay Garrity ends up after first his father and then his mother fall victim to the joblessness and despair that accompanies their steadily deteriorating lifestyle.

  • cover artBunting, Eve Fly Away Home. Picture Book. Grades 2-5. Order Info.
    A boy narrator tells us how he and his father live in the airport because they have no home.

  • Lowry, Lois Taking Care of Terrific. Novel. Grades 3-6. Order Info.
    Enid's babysitting job quickly involves her in a protest march by the homeless people of Boston.

  • Polacco, Patricia I Can Hear the Sun. Picture Book. Grades 2-5. Order Info.
    Polacco turns myth-maker in this story about a homeless child who befriends and is in turn befriended by a blind goose.

  • DiSalvo-Ryan, Dyanne Uncle Willie & the Soup Kitchen. Picture Book. Grades 2-4. Order Info.
    A boy goes with his uncle to work in a soup kitchen while his uncle explains that it is one way people can help the homeless.

  • Bunting, Eve December. Picture Book. Grades 2-7. Order Info.
    A boy and his mother live in a cardboard house on the streets.

  • Hahn, Mary Downing December Stillness. Novel. Grades 4-8. Order Info.
    Kelly becomes invovled with Mr. Weems, a homeless Vietnam vet, as part of a research project for school.

  • Curtis, Christopher Paul Bud, Not Buddy. Novel. Grades 4-8. Order Info.
    In this Newbery Award winning book ten-year-old Buddy, without resources other than his own self-constructed list of rules "To Have a Funner Life and Make a Better Liar Out of Yourself", will find love, a home and real family.

___________________

Related Areas Within Carol Hurst's Children's Literature Web Site

___________________

Related Areas Elsewhere on the Internet

Following these links will take you off our web site. You will have to use your back button to return or, bookmark our site now so you can return anytime.

Search Our Site



Subscribe to our Free Email Newsletter.
Sign Up!


Advertisements:


In Times Past
an eBook
by Carol Hurst and Rebecca Otis

Integrating US History with Literature in Grades 3-8.

In Times Past Cover

Enliven your US History curriculum!

Teach US History using great kids books.

More Info



By Carol Otis Hurst!!

cover art
Rocks in His Head.

Pick up your copy of Carol's Award Winning Picture Book!

More Information.


You can help fund this site at no cost to you! If you shop at Amazon.com bookstore use This Page each time you enter Amazon.com. More information.